The effective interest rate (EIR) is the real yearly cost of a loan. It takes into account that you repay the loan bit by bit each month, and it includes upfront fees such as a processing or admin fee. The advertised rate, often a “flat rate”, does neither. That is why a bank loan advertised at 3% a year can have an EIR closer to 6%.
When you compare two loan offers, compare the EIR (or the total amount you will repay), not the headline rate. This guide shows you how the gap arises, with worked examples you can check yourself.

Flat rate, reducing balance and EIR in one minute
Three terms come up again and again in loan offers:
Term | What it means | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
Flat rate | Interest is charged on the full original loan amount for the whole tenure, even as you pay it down | Makes a loan look cheaper than it is |
Reducing balance rate | Interest is charged only on what you still owe each month | A fairer basis; the number is higher than a flat rate for the same loan |
EIR | The reducing balance rate worked out as a yearly figure, with upfront fees included | The best single number for comparing offers |
For a broader introduction to how lenders charge interest, our guide on how interest is calculated on loans covers simple and compound interest. This article focuses on using EIR to compare real offers.
Why the EIR is almost double the flat rate
With a flat rate, you pay interest on the full amount for the entire loan, even though by the last month you owe almost nothing. On average over the loan, you only had about half the money borrowed. Paying interest on all of it means the true rate is close to double the flat rate.
Fees push it up further. If a lender takes a fee off the top, you receive less money but repay the same instalments, so your real cost of borrowing rises.
Worked example 1: a bank personal loan
EXAMPLE A bank offers $10,000 over 3 years at 3% a year flat.
Interest: $10,000 × 3% × 3 years = $900
Total repayment: $10,900, or about $302.78 a month for 36 months
EIR with no fees: about 5.8% a year
EIR with a 1% processing fee ($100 deducted, so you receive $9,900): about 6.5% a year
The 3% headline rate and the 6.5% EIR describe the same loan. Banks in Singapore usually print the EIR in smaller type next to the advertised rate, so look for it before you compare.
Worked example 2: a licensed moneylender loan
Licensed moneylenders usually quote a monthly rate. By law, it cannot be more than 4% a month, and interest is charged only on the principal you still owe. An upfront admin fee of up to 10% of the principal is allowed.
EXAMPLE A licensed moneylender offers $3,000 over 6 months at 2% a month on the reducing balance.
Monthly instalment: about $535.58
Total repayment: about $3,213, of which about $213 is interest
Effective cost with no fee: 2% a month, or about 27% a year
Effective cost if a 10% admin fee ($300) is taken off, so you receive $2,700: about 5.2% a month
The second figure is the one to notice. On a short loan, a large upfront fee has a big effect, because it is spread over only a few months. The interest rate is the same in both cases, but the fee more than doubles the real monthly cost.
This is why a lender with a lower monthly rate is not always cheaper. A lender charging 3% a month with no admin fee can cost less overall than one charging 2% a month with a 10% fee on a six-month loan.
Worked example 3: a “flat” monthly rate
Some lenders quote a monthly flat rate because it sounds low.
EXAMPLE $3,000 over 6 months at “1.5% a month flat”.
Interest: $3,000 × 1.5% × 6 = $270
Total repayment: $3,270, or $545 a month
Equivalent reducing balance rate: about 2.5% a month
So “1.5% flat” is really about 2.5% a month on what you owe. Always convert to the same basis before you compare.
How to compare loan offers properly
1. Ask for the EIR or the total repayment. Any licensed lender should be able to tell you the total amount you will pay back. If two loans are for the same amount and tenure, the one with the lower total is cheaper.
2. Check what is deducted upfront. Ask how much will actually reach your bank account. A $3,000 loan that pays out $2,700 is really a $2,700 loan.
3. Match the tenure. A longer loan has a lower instalment but usually costs more in total. Compare offers over the same number of months.
4. Read the late charges. For licensed moneylenders, late interest is capped at 4% a month on the overdue amount and late fees at $60 a month, but a missed payment still adds cost quickly.
5. Check early repayment terms. Ask whether you save interest by paying off early, and whether there is a fee for doing so.
Our loan calculator lets you test different amounts and tenures before you apply.
What the legal caps mean for EIR
For loans from licensed moneylenders, the Ministry of Law caps several costs:
interest of no more than 4% a month
an upfront admin fee of no more than 10% of the principal
total charges (interest, late interest, fees) that can never exceed the principal
The last cap gives you a hard ceiling. However the rate is quoted, you can never be charged more in total than the amount you borrowed, plus any court-ordered legal costs. Our guide to the Moneylenders Act explains the rest of the rules, including the three-business-day cooling-off period that lets you cancel an unsecured loan.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good EIR for a personal loan in Singapore?
It depends on the lender and your profile. Bank personal loans for borrowers with good credit often have EIRs in the mid single digits to low teens a year. Licensed moneylender loans cost more because they serve people banks often turn down, and the legal cap is 4% a month. Compare offers for the same amount and tenure.
Is EIR the same as APR?
They are close cousins. Both turn the cost of a loan into a yearly rate that includes fees. “EIR” is the term used by banks in Singapore; “APR” is more common in the US and UK. The exact calculation methods can differ slightly, so compare like with like.
Why is my EIR higher than the interest rate I was quoted?
Usually because the quoted rate is a flat rate, because a processing or admin fee was deducted, or both. The EIR reflects that you are paying the loan down each month and that you received less than the full amount.
Does paying off a loan early change the EIR?
It changes your total cost. Paying early usually means less interest overall, but an early repayment fee can eat into the saving. Ask the lender to show you the total cost of repaying early before you do it.
Is a lower monthly instalment always better?
No. A lower instalment usually comes from a longer tenure, which can mean paying more interest in total. Choose the shortest tenure whose instalment you can comfortably afford.
The number to remember
When you look at a loan, ask two questions: how much will reach my account, and how much will I repay in total? Those two figures, plus the tenure, tell you more than any advertised rate. If you would like a clear breakdown of a CashMax loan before deciding, see our loan interest rates or speak to us about a short-term loan quote with the total repayment set out in full.
